OBS vs ShadowPlay vs Medal: Which Should You Record With?
Nemo · · 7 min read
OBS vs ShadowPlay comes down to control against convenience. OBS Studio records anything on any graphics card, with scenes, a webcam and separate audio tracks, and takes setup. NVIDIA’s recorder, once called ShadowPlay and now part of the NVIDIA app, needs a GeForce card and works with two shortcuts. Medal is built around sharing short clips.
All three are free to record with, and all three use the graphics card’s hardware encoder, so none of them should cost you many frames. The differences are in what they capture, how much they let you change and what happens to the file afterwards. Facts here are as of November 2026.
What are OBS, ShadowPlay and Medal?
- OBS Studio is a free, open source app for recording and streaming on Windows, macOS and Linux. You build scenes out of sources (the game, a webcam, overlays) and it records or streams the result.
- ShadowPlay is the old name for NVIDIA’s recording tools. GeForce Experience was replaced by the NVIDIA app, and the features live in its overlay: Record, Instant Replay and Highlights. People still say ShadowPlay, so this post does too.
- Medal is a free clipping app for Windows PCs and phones. It keeps a rolling buffer of the game, saves the last moments on a hotkey, stores clips in its library and gives each one a share link. It has an optional paid plan on top.
How do OBS, ShadowPlay and Medal compare?
| OBS Studio | NVIDIA app (ShadowPlay) | Medal | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free, open source | Free with a GeForce card | Free, optional paid plan |
| Platforms | Windows, macOS, Linux | Windows | Windows, iOS, Android |
| Graphics card | Any | NVIDIA GeForce only | Any |
| Full-session recording | Yes | Yes (Alt+F9) | Yes |
| Save the last moments | Replay Buffer, your own hotkey | Instant Replay (Alt+F10) | Clip hotkey |
| Automatic clips in supported games | No | Highlights | Yes |
| Scenes with webcam and overlays | Yes, built from sources | No scenes | No scenes |
| Separate audio tracks | Up to 6, routed per source | Optional separate microphone track | Game, mic and Discord |
| File format | Your choice: Hybrid MP4, MKV, MOV and more | MP4 | MP4 |
| Live streaming | Yes | Not part of the recorder | No |
| Sharing | None, you get a file | None, you get a file | Cloud library and share links |
| Setup effort | High | Low | Low |
Shortcuts are the defaults and can be changed in each app.
When is OBS the better choice?
OBS wins when you need something the simple recorders don’t expose.
- You don’t have a GeForce card. OBS uses AMD’s and Intel’s hardware encoders too, and Apple’s on a Mac.
- You want more than the game in the picture. A webcam with a border, a chat box, an image overlay, a second monitor: scenes do that.
- You want audio you can fix later. OBS routes each source to its own track, so the game, your voice and Discord can be balanced after the fact.
- You care about the file. You choose the encoder, the rate control, the container and the folder. OBS recording settings for gameplay lists the choices that matter.
- You also stream. One app, one set of scenes.
The cost is time. OBS ships with no hotkeys assigned and a blank scene, and a wrong setting gives you a stuttering file or a black screen. OBS hotkeys and OBS recording lag cover the two most common first-week problems.
When is ShadowPlay the better choice?
NVIDIA’s recorder wins when you want recording to be invisible.
- There is nothing to build. Press Alt+Z, turn on Instant Replay, and Alt+F10 saves the last stretch from then on. The walk-through is in how to clip with NVIDIA.
- It comes from the card’s maker. The recorder is built for GeForce cards, so there is no encoder to choose or source to configure.
- Highlights saves some clips for you. In games that support it, kills and wins are saved without a key press.
- Quality options are short and sane. Resolution, frame rate, bitrate and codec, including AV1 on RTX 40 series cards and newer.
Its limits are the other side of the same coin: GeForce cards only, Windows only, one picture with little composition, and far fewer audio and format choices than OBS.
When is Medal the better choice?
Medal wins when the clip is the whole point and the audience is your friends.
- Sharing is built in. A clip gets a link within moments, with no upload step of your own.
- It organizes clips by game in a library, on the PC and on your phone.
- It clips automatically in supported games, and on a hotkey everywhere else.
Medal is less suited to recording as raw material. If the goal is a YouTube video or a batch of Shorts, you will still take the files into an editor, and settings control is lighter than in OBS. It also has no Mac version. Medal clips and its alternatives goes deeper.
Which uses fewer resources?
With a hardware encoder, the difference between the three is small on a modern PC, and it depends more on your settings than on the app. NVIDIA’s recorder has the fewest options to get wrong. OBS can be as light, or much heavier if a scene is full of browser sources and filters or the encoder is set to x264 on a busy CPU. Record ten minutes of your own game with each and compare the frame rate.
What happens after the recording?
None of the three finishes the job. OBS and NVIDIA leave you with a file. Medal leaves you with a clip and a link. A highlights video for YouTube or a set of vertical cuts for TikTok still has to be made.
GameClip is a desktop app for macOS and Windows that turns a gameplay recording into clips: one highlights video in 16:9 and vertical cuts in 9:16 for Shorts, Reels and TikTok. It opens recordings from all three: OBS, the NVIDIA app and Medal files open through New session, in MP4, MOV, MKV or WebM. You cut the plays on a timeline and it builds the outputs on your computer.
With OBS there is one more step available. GameClip can drive OBS’s recording: its keys start, pause and stop OBS, a key marks the last 30 seconds or 2 minutes while you play, and the file opens as a session with each mark already a clip. It doesn’t do that with the NVIDIA app or Medal, whose files you import afterwards. It also has its own recorder if you want neither. The setup is in the guide to connecting OBS Studio, and you can download GameClip here. It doesn’t host clips or give you share links, so Medal keeps that job.
What is the short answer?
- GeForce card, want it simple: the NVIDIA app.
- Any card, want control, a webcam scene or separate audio: OBS Studio.
- Want share links for friends in seconds: Medal.
FAQ
Is OBS better than ShadowPlay?
OBS is better for control: scenes, webcam, audio tracks, formats and any graphics card. ShadowPlay, now in the NVIDIA app, is better for ease: it works with two shortcuts and almost no setup on a GeForce card.
Does OBS or ShadowPlay use less FPS?
Both use the graphics card’s hardware encoder, so the gap is small. NVIDIA’s recorder is harder to misconfigure. OBS matches it with a hardware encoder and a simple scene, and costs more if the scene or the encoder settings are heavy.
Is ShadowPlay still a thing?
The name is retired, the features are not. Record, Instant Replay and Highlights are in the NVIDIA app, which replaced GeForce Experience. The overlay opens with Alt+Z.
Is OBS better than Medal?
For full recordings and editing material, yes: OBS gives you far more control over the picture, the audio and the file. For saving a moment and sending a link to friends, Medal is quicker.
Can I use OBS and ShadowPlay at the same time?
Yes, they can run together, though two recorders means the encoder works twice. A common split is Instant Replay for quick clips and OBS only when recording a full session.
Can GameClip use recordings from OBS, NVIDIA and Medal?
Yes. GameClip opens gameplay files from all three. With OBS Studio 28 or newer it can also control the recording and mark plays while you play.